HOME | NEWS | BAND | MUSIC | LIVE | FORUMS | MULTIMEDIA | SHOP | COMMUNITY | CONTACT US
Member Authentication
Forgot your password?
Become a member

New Order Related
Digital Republic
Ceremony
Music for pleasure
Weekly Song Reviews
 
International Forums
República Digital (Português)
République Numérique
Digitale Republik
Digitalrepubliken
República Digital (Español)
デジタル共和国
Digitalna Republika
Ψηφιακή Δημοκρατία
 
Off-Topic Forums
Behind Closed Doors
Buy/Trade/Sell
State of the Nation
 
Special Forums
World In Motion
Community
 
NewOrderOnline Related
NewOrderOnline Technical Chat
Customer Service
 
Subscriptions
Manage

LetItGo
PerfectKiss
luis
Giueseppe Eisonhawk
easypeasey
Christian Bachmann
Jon Massop
Paul Rose
Crystal Albert
mark brotherton
de zaim
el globo

New Order Seek to Balance Writing and the Road
New Order announces U.S. tour in July leading up to Lollapalooza appearance
Technical Issues
New Order to highlight Osheaga Festival
New Order 2013 Tour
New Order to Tour North America for the First Time in Seven Years
Doctor Hooky
The First Time I Heard Joy Division / New Order
New Order Video Interview
Peter Saville/Unknown Pleasures: donation to Fundraising Auction
New Order World Tour (Updated with US/CAN dates)
Working on a refresh
New Order's "Elegia" for Ian Curtis Is Now on Vinyl
New Order to Play Olympics Closing Ceremony
Guardian's review of New order's gig
SWING - ORIGINAL SOUNDTRACK BY GILLIAN & STEPHEN



NewOrderOnline.com is supported by its members. Donations are always welcomed and appreciated.

Send a donation...


Home » Forums » State of the Nation » Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Thread Starter: Richard Latanville
Started: 01/08/2005 8:40:06 AM - 8:40:06 AM
Replies: 28
Add Reply  
  NewOrderOnline Poll
Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?


Genius [45]
    [93.75%]
Twat [3]
    [6.25%]
48 vote(s) so far.
Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
NOOLigan  
Low-Life

what's the use in complaining when you've got what you don't need


Posts: 15,283
Member Since: 24/09/2003 6:43:56 PM
Location: Canberra, ACT, Australia
09/08/2005 9:31:18 PM - 9:31:18 PM
a bit of both , or should that be a lot of both.


What's the use in complaining, when you've got what you don't need.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Did'Ours  
Member of the Republic


Posts: 219
Member Since: 10/01/2003 2:25:58 AM
Location: FRANIERE, Namur, Belgium
09/08/2005 10:23:25 PM - 10:23:25 PM
GENIUS definitely !!!
That goes without saying.
And yes, he was a normal bloke (thank Heavens)like all of us... But inni't one of the aspect we love so much about NEWorder/Joy Division : their Human side 1st of all...
That always kept me closer to their Music than anyone else.
That's 1 of the many points that make them TRULY UNIQUE.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Did'Ours  
Member of the Republic


Posts: 219
Member Since: 10/01/2003 2:25:58 AM
Location: FRANIERE, Namur, Belgium
09/08/2005 10:23:25 PM - 10:23:25 PM
GENIUS definitely !!!
That goes without saying.
And yes, he was a normal bloke (thank Heavens)like all of us... But inni't one of the aspect we love so much about NEWorder/Joy Division : their Human side 1st of all...
That always kept me closer to their Music than anyone else.
That's 1 of the many points that make them TRULY UNIQUE.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Jesu  
Low-Life

The life and times...


Posts: 6,671
Member Since: 11/06/2005 12:17:10 PM
Location: Belfast, Ireland
16/08/2005 3:00:18 PM - 3:00:18 PM
Geniarse.

A normal man who wrote extrodinary lyrics to extrodinary songs.


"I don't necessarily agree with everything I think."

Von's First Law Of The Internet: "The Net is allergic to truth, reason and humour."

Andrew Eldritch


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Jesu  
Low-Life

The life and times...


Posts: 6,671
Member Since: 11/06/2005 12:17:10 PM
Location: Belfast, Ireland
16/08/2005 3:00:18 PM - 3:00:18 PM
Geniarse.

A normal man who wrote extrodinary lyrics to extrodinary songs.


"I don't necessarily agree with everything I think."

Von's First Law Of The Internet: "The Net is allergic to truth, reason and humour."

Andrew Eldritch


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Chris owen  
Member of the Republic

Remember why I'm telling you


Posts: 222
Member Since: 14/07/2004 6:33:35 PM
Location: Connah's Quay, North Wales, United Kingdom
17/08/2005 4:42:52 PM - 4:42:52 PM
A tragic, troubled genius whose legacy will never be forgotten as long as music lives on. I can think of no other lyricist brave enough to take a scalpel to their soul and display the wounds for all to see. His lyrics are deep, dark, poetry.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Chris owen  
Member of the Republic

Remember why I'm telling you


Posts: 222
Member Since: 14/07/2004 6:33:35 PM
Location: Connah's Quay, North Wales, United Kingdom
17/08/2005 4:42:52 PM - 4:42:52 PM
A tragic, troubled genius whose legacy will never be forgotten as long as music lives on. I can think of no other lyricist brave enough to take a scalpel to their soul and display the wounds for all to see. His lyrics are deep, dark, poetry.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
mil  
Member of the Movement

"Was that ever realeased here in Australia? Have you ever heard that song before?" - Bernard


Posts: 702
Member Since: 28/06/2005 5:15:25 PM
Location: , Australia
26/08/2005 3:36:32 AM - 3:36:32 AM
Reading 'touching from a distance' one leans towards twat. But then you listen to the music... the lyrics...

I think he was a man with a lost of problems... who made great lyrics and music. When you match the lyrics with his experiences - its brilliant poetry. Those lyrics were really expressing real, deep hurt.

Hard question for a definite answer I suppose.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
mil  
Member of the Movement

"Was that ever realeased here in Australia? Have you ever heard that song before?" - Bernard


Posts: 702
Member Since: 28/06/2005 5:15:25 PM
Location: , Australia
26/08/2005 3:36:32 AM - 3:36:32 AM
Reading 'touching from a distance' one leans towards twat. But then you listen to the music... the lyrics...

I think he was a man with a lost of problems... who made great lyrics and music. When you match the lyrics with his experiences - its brilliant poetry. Those lyrics were really expressing real, deep hurt.

Hard question for a definite answer I suppose.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
johnboy586  
Young Offender


Posts: 35
Member Since: 09/02/2002 7:42:32 PM
Location: Blacko, Nelson, Lancashire, United Kingdom
26/08/2005 3:45:05 AM - 3:45:05 AM
80 % Genius...20% twat (he read the daily mail, voted conservative and abit of a shit towards his wife)


http://www.last.fm/user/johnboy586


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
johnboy586  
Young Offender


Posts: 35
Member Since: 09/02/2002 7:42:32 PM
Location: Blacko, Nelson, Lancashire, United Kingdom
26/08/2005 3:45:05 AM - 3:45:05 AM
80 % Genius...20% twat (he read the daily mail, voted conservative and abit of a shit towards his wife)


http://www.last.fm/user/johnboy586


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
ze t  
Member of the Republic




Posts: 108
Member Since: 20/01/2005 3:31:46 AM

26/08/2005 4:24:53 AM - 4:24:53 AM
A genius or an outstanding poet.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
ze t  
Member of the Republic




Posts: 108
Member Since: 20/01/2005 3:31:46 AM

26/08/2005 4:24:53 AM - 4:24:53 AM
A genius or an outstanding poet.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
johnny  
Low-Life

Rum Deal


Posts: 8,044
Member Since: 06/04/2004 5:42:25 PM
Location: Deep In The Heart Of , Where Sympathy Held Sway, United Kingdom (England)
04/09/2005 4:38:02 AM - 4:38:02 AM
Just find it incredible sometimes to think he wrote those lyrics at such a young age.late teens and early twenties.You`d think the lyrics were written by someone ancient.


Bloody wife hater.

Edited by: johnny on 04/09/2005 3:00:02 PM - 3:00:02 PM


"I`ve always wanted to be American.You get so excited.It`s wonderful!"


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
johnny  
Low-Life

Rum Deal


Posts: 8,044
Member Since: 06/04/2004 5:42:25 PM
Location: Deep In The Heart Of , Where Sympathy Held Sway, United Kingdom (England)
04/09/2005 4:38:02 AM - 4:38:02 AM
Just find it incredible sometimes to think he wrote those lyrics at such a young age.late teens and early twenties.You`d think the lyrics were written by someone ancient.


Bloody wife hater.

Edited by: johnny on 04/09/2005 3:00:02 PM - 3:00:02 PM


"I`ve always wanted to be American.You get so excited.It`s wonderful!"


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
eleusis  
Candidate


Posts: 2
Member Since: 23/08/2005 1:39:58 PM

06/09/2005 2:18:35 PM - 2:18:35 PM
I think it was Thackeray (hope I've spelt his name right) who said that comparing the mind of Shakespeare with that of an ordinary man was like comparing the length of two maggots. An enigmatic statement I suppose, but I think he was saying that he did not believe in the concept of genius. Curtis was a twat for killing himself perhaps. I heard Tony Wilson say on Australian radio that Curtis should have hung around (no pun intended) until JD got to America then he could have shagged his way across the States and become a relatively happy man again. His death was probably the most unromantic in the history of rock. To hang oneself above a washer/dryer...


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
eleusis  
Candidate


Posts: 2
Member Since: 23/08/2005 1:39:58 PM

06/09/2005 2:18:35 PM - 2:18:35 PM
I think it was Thackeray (hope I've spelt his name right) who said that comparing the mind of Shakespeare with that of an ordinary man was like comparing the length of two maggots. An enigmatic statement I suppose, but I think he was saying that he did not believe in the concept of genius. Curtis was a twat for killing himself perhaps. I heard Tony Wilson say on Australian radio that Curtis should have hung around (no pun intended) until JD got to America then he could have shagged his way across the States and become a relatively happy man again. His death was probably the most unromantic in the history of rock. To hang oneself above a washer/dryer...


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
UpDownTurnAround  
Weirdo

...


Posts: 3,637
Member Since: 19/06/2003 6:07:02 AM
Location: DiametricWgtns, New Zealand
08/09/2005 4:09:08 AM - 4:09:08 AM
Musically - 100% Genius.

As a human / socially - 50% twat (but aren't we all as we grow).


http://www.20six.co.uk/tryharder


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
UpDownTurnAround  
Weirdo

...


Posts: 3,637
Member Since: 19/06/2003 6:07:02 AM
Location: DiametricWgtns, New Zealand
08/09/2005 4:09:08 AM - 4:09:08 AM
Musically - 100% Genius.

As a human / socially - 50% twat (but aren't we all as we grow).


http://www.20six.co.uk/tryharder


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Church of the KLF  
Skullcrusher

Zing!


Posts: 2,722
Member Since: 03/12/2002 1:44:21 PM
Location: Sunnyisde, Queens, New York City, United States of America
08/09/2005 2:45:25 PM - 2:45:25 PM
An absolute genius and a complete and utter twat. His presence in the history of pop music is unsurpassable and possesses a completely unique brilliance, but he was a selfish bastard in his personal life.


Doctorin' the Tardis.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Church of the KLF  
Skullcrusher

Zing!


Posts: 2,722
Member Since: 03/12/2002 1:44:21 PM
Location: Sunnyisde, Queens, New York City, United States of America
08/09/2005 2:45:25 PM - 2:45:25 PM
An absolute genius and a complete and utter twat. His presence in the history of pop music is unsurpassable and possesses a completely unique brilliance, but he was a selfish bastard in his personal life.


Doctorin' the Tardis.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
La Paula  
Young Offender


Posts: 32
Member Since: 01/08/2005 11:15:59 PM
Location: Manchester,England, United Kingdom
03/12/2005 4:22:12 AM - 4:22:12 AM
Ian is very Genius.
but sometimes twat.'S blood!!!!!


I am human and I need to be love...
In a room with a window in the corner,I found truth


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
La Paula  
Young Offender


Posts: 32
Member Since: 01/08/2005 11:15:59 PM
Location: Manchester,England, United Kingdom
03/12/2005 4:22:12 AM - 4:22:12 AM
Ian is very Genius.
but sometimes twat.'S blood!!!!!


I am human and I need to be love...
In a room with a window in the corner,I found truth


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
Wit?  
Member with Substance


Posts: 1,227
Member Since: 08/04/2006 8:43:44 PM
Location: Under your bed!,
18/04/2006 1:49:07 PM - 1:49:07 PM
Lyracial,poetic genius. The only dark/depressing etc,etc,etc Puking thing about him was the poor bastards epilespy.


Red held deep inside of me.


Author Re: Ian Curtis: Genius or twat?
The Small-Town Order  
Skullcrusher

Oi...? --OI!! Viking


Posts: 2,898
Member Since: 21/01/2007 4:35:13 PM
Location: The Small-Town Underground, DeLand, Florida, United States of America
21/01/2007 8:25:18 PM - 8:25:18 PM
 fitz wrote:
Genius Bow , Poet Great! , and Twat Bang Head

I'll humbly admit, Ian is as follows:

75% genius.
24% poet.
1% twat.

'Nuff said. Gotta love the man.


~ 'Sunshine'


 
Add Reply
  Page 2 of 3 (53 items) < 1 2 3 >