HOME | NEWS | BAND | MUSIC | LIVE | FORUMS | MULTIMEDIA | SHOP | COMMUNITY | CONTACT US
Member Authentication
Forgot your password?
Become a member

New Order Related
Digital Republic
Ceremony
Music for pleasure
Weekly Song Reviews
 
International Forums
República Digital (Português)
République Numérique
Digitale Republik
Digitalrepubliken
República Digital (Español)
デジタル共和国
Digitalna Republika
Ψηφιακή Δημοκρατία
 
Off-Topic Forums
Behind Closed Doors
Buy/Trade/Sell
State of the Nation
 
Special Forums
World In Motion
Community
 
NewOrderOnline Related
NewOrderOnline Technical Chat
Customer Service
 
Subscriptions
Manage

'WELSHCAKE'
ed verrilla
Leigh maude
hello.image
sweens308
Ed Sander
Aster Luu
coolot521
jonathan dien

New Order Seek to Balance Writing and the Road
New Order announces U.S. tour in July leading up to Lollapalooza appearance
Technical Issues
New Order to highlight Osheaga Festival
New Order 2013 Tour
New Order to Tour North America for the First Time in Seven Years
Doctor Hooky
The First Time I Heard Joy Division / New Order
New Order Video Interview
Peter Saville/Unknown Pleasures: donation to Fundraising Auction
New Order World Tour (Updated with US/CAN dates)
Working on a refresh
New Order's "Elegia" for Ian Curtis Is Now on Vinyl
New Order to Play Olympics Closing Ceremony
Guardian's review of New order's gig
SWING - ORIGINAL SOUNDTRACK BY GILLIAN & STEPHEN



NewOrderOnline.com is supported by its members. Donations are always welcomed and appreciated.

Send a donation...


Home » Forums » State of the Nation » Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Thread Starter: Spotnick
Started: 25/02/2004 5:15:05 PM - 5:15:05 PM
Replies: 39
Add Reply  
  NewOrderOnline Poll
Which one do you prefer?


Monaco - Music For Pleasure [27]
    [34.18%]
New Order - Republic [52]
    [65.82%]
79 vote(s) so far.
Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
El Jarvo  
Viking

Phat Boys


Posts: 14,874
Member Since: 01/09/2001 7:53:03 AM
Location: Snorebans, United Kingdom (England)
26/02/2004 11:21:40 AM - 11:21:40 AM
[quote][i]Originally posted by robin[/i]
[b]I voted for Republic, but I do think Music for Pleasure gets a bad rap. Granted Nick Mason's production mutes some of the chaos, but what do you expect from a member of Pink Floyd. Problem Child, Don't Cry Wolf, and One Way Love are the stand out tracks for me.[/b][/quote] O-kay. Took me a while to get that one. :thumb:


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
DoN  
Salvation Member


Posts: 4,452
Member Since: 11/10/2001 4:39:41 AM
Location: London, United Kingdom
26/02/2004 11:28:41 AM - 11:28:41 AM
Hmm... pollspollspollspolls seems like we've been here before :skeptic:


"Remember, life is strange and life keeps getting stranger every day..."


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
DoN  
Salvation Member


Posts: 4,452
Member Since: 11/10/2001 4:39:41 AM
Location: London, United Kingdom
26/02/2004 11:28:41 AM - 11:28:41 AM
Hmm... pollspollspollspolls seems like we've been here before :skeptic:


"Remember, life is strange and life keeps getting stranger every day..."


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Elias  
Salvation Member


Posts: 277
Member Since: 11/12/2002 3:02:52 AM
Location: Heraklion, Greece
26/02/2004 12:46:18 PM - 12:46:18 PM
Easy this one: Republic may not be the best NO album, still its better than Monaco's one.


How old are u, are u old enough?


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Elias  
Salvation Member


Posts: 277
Member Since: 11/12/2002 3:02:52 AM
Location: Heraklion, Greece
26/02/2004 12:46:18 PM - 12:46:18 PM
Easy this one: Republic may not be the best NO album, still its better than Monaco's one.


How old are u, are u old enough?


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
robin  
Member of the Republic




Posts: 178
Member Since: 22/04/2003 10:29:45 AM
Location: Birmingham, AL, United States of America
26/02/2004 1:10:19 PM - 1:10:19 PM
[quote][i]Originally posted by [b]Al Jarvis[/b][/i]
[b][quote][i]Originally posted by robin[/i]
[b]I voted for Republic, but I do think Music for Pleasure gets a bad rap. Granted Nick Mason's production mutes some of the chaos, but what do you expect from a member of Pink Floyd. Problem Child, Don't Cry Wolf, and One Way Love are the stand out tracks for me.[/b][/quote] O-kay. Took me a while to get that one. :thumb:[/b][/quote] I'm just glad someone did. Bit myopic around these parts sometimes. Maybe that would be a good poll: The 2 MFP's squaring off. I know who I'd vote for as I can't envision a scenario in which the Monaco album would ever be coming through my speakers ever again.


support your local growers


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
robin  
Member of the Republic




Posts: 178
Member Since: 22/04/2003 10:29:45 AM
Location: Birmingham, AL, United States of America
26/02/2004 1:10:19 PM - 1:10:19 PM
[quote][i]Originally posted by [b]Al Jarvis[/b][/i]
[b][quote][i]Originally posted by robin[/i]
[b]I voted for Republic, but I do think Music for Pleasure gets a bad rap. Granted Nick Mason's production mutes some of the chaos, but what do you expect from a member of Pink Floyd. Problem Child, Don't Cry Wolf, and One Way Love are the stand out tracks for me.[/b][/quote] O-kay. Took me a while to get that one. :thumb:[/b][/quote] I'm just glad someone did. Bit myopic around these parts sometimes. Maybe that would be a good poll: The 2 MFP's squaring off. I know who I'd vote for as I can't envision a scenario in which the Monaco album would ever be coming through my speakers ever again.


support your local growers


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
anita  
Member of the Movement


Posts: 736
Member Since: 05/01/2002 10:27:56 PM
Location: Riverside, OH, United States of America
26/02/2004 9:52:00 PM - 9:52:00 PM
republic...i think i only like a couple of hooky's side project songs


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
anita  
Member of the Movement


Posts: 736
Member Since: 05/01/2002 10:27:56 PM
Location: Riverside, OH, United States of America
26/02/2004 9:52:00 PM - 9:52:00 PM
republic...i think i only like a couple of hooky's side project songs


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
poisoned Snickers r yummy...  
Member with Technique

I am HORROR


Posts: 788
Member Since: 22/10/2001 10:17:38 AM
Location: Newcastle & Sydney, Australia
26/02/2004 11:30:59 PM - 11:30:59 PM
...I really like MONACO ( God bless that bass!!! ) and I thought MUSIC FOR PLEASURE sounded brilliant..... for the first 6 months ....but a bit like a piece of bubblegum - it felt empty after a while...and funny thing is now, listening to REPUBLIC ( after ignoring it for nearly 10 years, eventhough I have 5 versions of that CD...) it sounds better than I first heard it...maybe I had higher expectations the first time around. Anyway, I still have to go for MONACO cuz I think MUSIC FOR PLEASURE is the best release for any Hooky's side project!! ( anyone know how to get their hands on the 2-LP vinyl version of this?..thanks )


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
poisoned Snickers r yummy...  
Member with Technique

I am HORROR


Posts: 788
Member Since: 22/10/2001 10:17:38 AM
Location: Newcastle & Sydney, Australia
26/02/2004 11:30:59 PM - 11:30:59 PM
...I really like MONACO ( God bless that bass!!! ) and I thought MUSIC FOR PLEASURE sounded brilliant..... for the first 6 months ....but a bit like a piece of bubblegum - it felt empty after a while...and funny thing is now, listening to REPUBLIC ( after ignoring it for nearly 10 years, eventhough I have 5 versions of that CD...) it sounds better than I first heard it...maybe I had higher expectations the first time around. Anyway, I still have to go for MONACO cuz I think MUSIC FOR PLEASURE is the best release for any Hooky's side project!! ( anyone know how to get their hands on the 2-LP vinyl version of this?..thanks )


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
death of art  
Member with Technique


Posts: 804
Member Since: 22/07/2003 4:45:23 PM
Location: The North, United Kingdom
01/03/2004 5:26:12 PM - 5:26:12 PM
[quote][i]Originally posted by Doctor Clayhead[/i]
[b]Yeah, but what about those annoying sub-Oasis tunes that really drag MFP waaaaaaaaay down??????????[/b][/quote] My thoughts exactly. Besides, although MFP has some good tunes, it lacks Barney's singing - Hooky can't sing and Pottsy may as well be Barney, but without that little air of vulnerability that makes NO so good. Good poll though - the worst NO album v one of the best side project ones.


"You have the mouth of a prattling jackanapes ... but your eyes ... they tell a different story"


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
death of art  
Member with Technique


Posts: 804
Member Since: 22/07/2003 4:45:23 PM
Location: The North, United Kingdom
01/03/2004 5:26:12 PM - 5:26:12 PM
[quote][i]Originally posted by Doctor Clayhead[/i]
[b]Yeah, but what about those annoying sub-Oasis tunes that really drag MFP waaaaaaaaay down??????????[/b][/quote] My thoughts exactly. Besides, although MFP has some good tunes, it lacks Barney's singing - Hooky can't sing and Pottsy may as well be Barney, but without that little air of vulnerability that makes NO so good. Good poll though - the worst NO album v one of the best side project ones.


"You have the mouth of a prattling jackanapes ... but your eyes ... they tell a different story"


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Ben  
Skullcrusher

Peel slowly and see.


Posts: 2,736
Member Since: 13/08/2001 12:00:00 AM
Location: Brussels, Belgium
02/03/2004 7:15:26 AM - 7:15:26 AM
Never liked Monaco, and probably never will... So it's got to be Republic for me.

Edited by: Ben on 02/03/2004 7:15:52 AM - 7:15:52 AM


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Ben  
Skullcrusher

Peel slowly and see.


Posts: 2,736
Member Since: 13/08/2001 12:00:00 AM
Location: Brussels, Belgium
02/03/2004 7:15:26 AM - 7:15:26 AM
Never liked Monaco, and probably never will... So it's got to be Republic for me.

Edited by: Ben on 02/03/2004 7:15:52 AM - 7:15:52 AM


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Steve #1  
Low-Life

Smack My Glitch Up


Posts: 6,707
Member Since: 12/12/2003 2:35:40 PM
Location: , United Kingdom (England)
02/03/2004 8:13:42 AM - 8:13:42 AM
[quote][i]Originally posted by Tout est devenu [i][lime]vert[/lime][/i][/i]
[b]Never liked Monaco, and probably never will...[/b][/quote] Its great when the Grand Prix is on! :D


Im not a mod or a rocker,im a mocker.


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Steve #1  
Low-Life

Smack My Glitch Up


Posts: 6,707
Member Since: 12/12/2003 2:35:40 PM
Location: , United Kingdom (England)
02/03/2004 8:13:42 AM - 8:13:42 AM
[quote][i]Originally posted by Tout est devenu [i][lime]vert[/lime][/i][/i]
[b]Never liked Monaco, and probably never will...[/b][/quote] Its great when the Grand Prix is on! :D


Im not a mod or a rocker,im a mocker.


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
feline  
Member of the Brotherhood


Posts: 342
Member Since: 27/11/2002 6:58:39 PM
Location: Iraklion, Crete, Greece
02/03/2004 10:18:06 AM - 10:18:06 AM
Republic by a light year! I only like two songs from MFP: WDYWFM and Shine


Come forth, Lazarus. And he came fifth and lost the job.


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
feline  
Member of the Brotherhood


Posts: 342
Member Since: 27/11/2002 6:58:39 PM
Location: Iraklion, Crete, Greece
02/03/2004 10:18:06 AM - 10:18:06 AM
Republic by a light year! I only like two songs from MFP: WDYWFM and Shine


Come forth, Lazarus. And he came fifth and lost the job.


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Spider in a Land of Meat  
Member with Substance

Spider Made of Meat


Posts: 1,119
Member Since: 16/09/2002 9:52:23 AM
Location: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
02/03/2004 2:37:41 PM - 2:37:41 PM
You may not believe it, but it's true: if you burn them together, the fire is green. Try it.


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Spider in a Land of Meat  
Member with Substance

Spider Made of Meat


Posts: 1,119
Member Since: 16/09/2002 9:52:23 AM
Location: Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
02/03/2004 2:37:41 PM - 2:37:41 PM
You may not believe it, but it's true: if you burn them together, the fire is green. Try it.


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
AgentWood  
Salvation Member

so it goes....


Posts: 9,416
Member Since: 02/09/2002 10:56:34 PM
Location: New London, CT, United States Minor Outlying Islands
02/03/2004 3:39:36 PM - 3:39:36 PM
music for pleasure. sorry NO, but i'm going with hooky's baby on this one. just a better album, IMO. or, rather, fewer crap songs.


So it goes.--KV


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
AgentWood  
Salvation Member

so it goes....


Posts: 9,416
Member Since: 02/09/2002 10:56:34 PM
Location: New London, CT, United States Minor Outlying Islands
02/03/2004 3:39:36 PM - 3:39:36 PM
music for pleasure. sorry NO, but i'm going with hooky's baby on this one. just a better album, IMO. or, rather, fewer crap songs.


So it goes.--KV


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Server Error in "/" Application  
Salvation Member


Posts: 2,604
Member Since: 16/03/2003 9:52:10 PM
Location: , Brazil
02/03/2004 4:49:41 PM - 4:49:41 PM
[quote][i]Originally posted by The Spider Is Dead[/i]
[b]You may not believe it, but it's true: if you burn them together, the fire is green. Try it.[/b][/quote] Looked normal to me when I... dammit, it was Music for the Masses and Republica... :mad2: No, wait... ok, then! :)


Author Re: Music For Pleasure vs Republic
Server Error in "/" Application  
Salvation Member


Posts: 2,604
Member Since: 16/03/2003 9:52:10 PM
Location: , Brazil
02/03/2004 4:49:41 PM - 4:49:41 PM
[quote][i]Originally posted by The Spider Is Dead[/i]
[b]You may not believe it, but it's true: if you burn them together, the fire is green. Try it.[/b][/quote] Looked normal to me when I... dammit, it was Music for the Masses and Republica... :mad2: No, wait... ok, then! :)


 
Add Reply
  Page 2 of 3 (75 items) < 1 2 3 >